“Good enough” in a leadership seat is the most expensive standard in your company. You will not see the bill for a long time. When it finally arrives, you will not be able to trace it back to the decisions that caused it.
Watch the full video:
What I Watched on Monday Night
I am slowly becoming a serious football fan, and I did not expect what comes with it. I keep learning how a football team is run, and it is a clear picture of how football is a business, but it doesn’t always get run like one.
Monday night, the Minnesota Vikings played the Buffalo Bills at home. Carson Wentz had one of the worst games a quarterback can have. Everyone has a bad day, and that part is okay. What stuck with me was the pile of decisions behind that bad day.
The quarterback is the leader on the field. Every other player’s points, every win, runs through that seat. Here is the short version of what has happened to it.
Kirk Cousins signed with the Vikings in 2018 and started for six seasons. That first run ended in October 2023 with a torn Achilles at Lambeau Field. The Vikings signed Sam Darnold on a one-year deal, and Darnold led them to a 14 and 3 season. They also drafted J.J. McCarthy 10th overall, and McCarthy missed the entire rookie year with an injury.
After that, the seat turned into a rotation. Wentz, Kyler Murray, and others kept coming in and going out. As a fan, it was painful to watch. Nobody on that field could be sure who the leader was from one week to the next.
A team can have talent everywhere else and still not be able to run when the leadership seat is unclear. Your business works the same way.
The Tuesday Morning Decision
The next morning, the conversations started. That day, within 24 hours, the Vikings traded for Kirk Cousins, who came back from the Las Vegas Raiders for a 2027 third-round pick. Cousins was reunited with head coach Kevin O’Connell and stepped straight into the starting lineup.
I do not know if it will work. Nobody does. What I admire is what they did. In the middle of the season, they looked at the plan and said, “This is not working. We have to adjust now.” They did not wait for the offseason to feel comfortable about it.
Football coaches live with this every week. They never know for certain who will be playing when the game starts, and any player can be injured and out within minutes. They have a backup ready and they train for the swap.
Now ask yourself the same question about your company. Any one of your people could be gone tomorrow. Who is your backup? Have you cross-trained anyone so you are not scrambling?
Why Unconventional Leaders Wait Too Long
Almost every leader I work with can see when someone is in the wrong seat. Most of them wait far longer than they should, and I think I know why.
Many of us went through a school system that did not know how to educate us, and it gave up on us. We could not give up back, because we had to keep going to graduate. There was no plan to help us. Some of us turned out to be brilliant, and plenty of us were very good at things nobody was measuring. We were waiting for someone to give us a chance.
That teaches you a belief. Everyone can do something if they just get the right support. And we know exactly what it feels like to be rejected and abandoned, so we refuse to be the one who makes anyone else feel that way.
That belief is a strength. It is a big part of why you built a company people want to work for. It also has a blind spot. You give the benefit of the doubt for far too long, and you stop noticing what it does to your culture, your bottom line, and your results.
Resilience works the same way. You were taught to give 150% when the odds were against you, and that is how you got here. Used on the wrong problem, it keeps you fighting for something that will not change.
The Plant Manager Who Got Two Years
One of my clients had a middle manager on a manufacturing plant floor. The manager was a poor communicator, created drama, struggled to delegate, and was unclear about the goals and expectations for the team. Most of the manager’s energy went into making sure nobody on the team ever disliked them.
The turnover in that department ran three times higher than the rest of the company. Production was down. The people who stayed were frustrated and angry.
My client could not make the call. This manager had been a good, productive, and loyal employee for many years, and my client saw leadership potential worth growing. So my client sent the manager to training twice. After each round, things got worse.
It went on for two years. Then my client moved the manager out of the role. The people who remained were relieved. The culture improved, production went up, and people stopped quitting and transferring to other departments.
Notice what my client did right. My client said what the seat needed, invested in the growth twice, and gave full effort. The problem was that nobody had a way to say “this is the point where we stop.”
What the Wait Really Costs
The cost is bigger than the department. It is your own confidence.
Leaders who wait too long start to second-guess themselves in other areas. If I cannot figure this out, maybe I do not know what I am doing. Maybe I should not be running this company. Doubt, anxiety, and old stories start draining your confidence, and the doubt spreads to decisions that have nothing to do with the problem.
The money cost hides well. Replacing employees is expensive. More accidents happen when leadership is poor. All of it hits the bottom line slowly, so no single bad decision gets the blame, and by the time you look back it is hard to trace the damage to its source.
Why You No Longer Have Time to Wait
Waiting always cost something. Now it costs more, and it costs it faster. Business moves quicker every month, and AI is a big reason why. Employee roles and duties are changing faster than most job descriptions can keep up with.
That means the person who was the right fit for a seat two years ago may be a mismatch for what that seat needs today. Nobody did anything wrong. The seat changed.
Go back to the plant manager. In a slower market, two years of waiting cost a department its production and its people. In this market, it can cost you your window.
You and your leadership team need to be able to pivot mid-season, or sooner, if you want to be as successful as you can be. The Vikings did not wait for the offseason to feel comfortable. Which seats in your company are changing because of AI? Does the person in each one have the skills that seat needs now, or the ones it needed when they were hired?
How to Know When to Cut Your Losses
I use two checks with clients. First, I listen to how much complaining and how many excuses I am hearing about why something cannot be done. A lot of either tells me how emotionally connected the leader is to the person, and that connection affects how clearly the leader can see. Second, I ask whether the leader can explain exactly what they need this person to do. If they can, have they invested in helping this person grow in that area?
Then I walk through these steps with them.
- Name the seat. Write down what the role needs this person to do, in plain words.
- Check yourself first. How much complaining and how many excuses are you hearing, from them or from you? That tells you how close you are to the person.
- Check the investment. Have you taught or trained them on exactly that skill? What happened?
- Look at the team under them. Check turnover, output, mood, PTO days for the department, injuries, and pushback to change.
- Find the final piece. What is the one thing you still need to know to confirm what others are already seeing?
- Set a date. Pick a deadline for the call, and write it down.
If you have been avoiding this conversation because you care about people, I wrote more about the other side of that instinct in Strategy #3 from The Unconventional Leadership Playbook: Ending People-Pleasing.
Related: Ending People-Pleasing:
Football also taught me a few uncomfortable lessons earlier this year. You can read them in Fantasy Football Top 10 Takeaways for Leaders.
Related: A Leader’s Responsibility to Their Team
Your Turn
Think of one seat in your company where you keep saying “they are doing okay.” Whose name came to mind first?
Write down in one sentence what that seat needs. Then put a date on your calendar this week for step 5, the final thing you need to know. What is the one piece of information that would settle it for you?
JoyGenea Schumer
Personal Development Expert To The Unconventional Leaders
AI Prompt:
Introduction to the AI Prompt
You have a seat in your company that you have called okay for a long time. This week’s blog and video use the Vikings’ quarterback trade to show why leaders wait too long, and what it costs. The prompt below turns that into a focused 10 to 15 minute session with your AI tool, built to surface the blind spot behind the wait. Copy the prompt below, paste it into your AI tool of choice, and give it 10 to 15 minutes.
Custom AI Prompt
You are my direct, peer-level thinking partner for this session. You have no agenda to protect, and you are not a therapist or a cheerleader.
This is a focused 10 to 15 minute session. Ask me one question at a time so I can stay in the work without getting overwhelmed.
Here is the framework: there is a seat on my team where the person is doing okay, not bad, not great. I have kept giving the benefit of the doubt, and I want to find what that wait is costing my operating system, my confidence, and my team’s capacity.
Ask me these, one at a time, going progressively deeper:
- Which seat is it, what does that role need the person to do now, in plain words, and how have AI or new tools changed it?
- How much complaining and how many excuses do I hear about this person, from them, from others, and in my own head? What does that say about how attached I am?
- What has happened each time I trained or supported them on that exact skill?
- What is happening on the team under that seat: turnover, output, mood, time off, injuries, pushback to change? Which signal am I ignoring?
- Where did I learn to give people endless runway, and where is that habit creating friction in my leadership today?
When I have answered all five, summarize the one blind spot you see running through my answers. Then give me one concrete action I can take before the end of today, including a date to make the call.
Video Transcript:
Hey. So I just got back. By the way, it’s getting cold here in Minnesota. I have got a great story to share with you this week. You’re gonna love it. So in case you didn’t know, I’m slowly becoming a Minnesota Vikings fan. It’s not that I exactly have a choice in the matter, my husband’s pretty into it, and this last week, yeah, the Vikings were teaching us a valuable lesson.
A really valuable lesson for unconventional leaders. So picture in your mind, and I know you can, that one person you’ve been meaning to let go of. You know the one who isn’t really good at their job, isn’t really bad, they’re just, oh, yeah, good enough I know you can already name this person. You have them fully pictured in your mind.
The one in the seat who is doing okay. Okay is not what we want in our seats and working for us. And you keep telling yourself, “I’m gonna deal with that soon.” Well, hang around. You’re gonna learn more. I’m JoyGenea, and I work with unconventional leaders, really kind, really amazing leaders. And this week, a football team showed me and reminded me of what the real cost is of waiting around.
I’m slowly, like I said, becoming a f- a football fan, which means sometimes Monday nights have to be a research night, which a couple weeks ago, actually last week, was Monday Night Football. Minnesota Vikings hosted the Buffalo Bills. Carson Wentz had one of the worst games a quarterback I’ve ever seen.
Everyone has a bad day, but, well, ugh, that part was not okay. What stuck out to me was the pile of decisions behind it. The quarterback is the leader on the field. Every part and every win runs through that seat. It’s like it’s the most important thing. So if you don’t know much about the Minnesota Vikings, here’s a quick history of our quarterback situation.
Six years ago, we had Kirk Cousins. He had an Achilles issue October of 2023. Then came Sam Dar- Sam Darnold for a one-year deal and a 14 and three season, which was amazing, didn’t amount to anything. The Vikings also drafted J.J. McCarthy, 10th overall draft. McCarthy missed the whole rookie year with an injury.
After that, the seat became a rotation of Wentz, Kyler Murray, and others kept coming and going. Are you feeling this? See where this might be happening at your business? As a fan, okay, it was just painful to watch. Nobody on the field knew who the leader was. It wasn’t consistent from week to week. Football is a business.
Don’t kid yourself. It’s a multimillion-dollar business. It just does not always run the same way as a lot of other businesses. It, it doesn’t. The seat… The employees are consistently shuffling. It’s different. So then Tuesday morning, these conversations starts. Lots of mumbling about, “Oh, no, the Vikings.” And within 24 hours, right at the trade deadline, they s- got Kirk Cousins to come back to Minnesota from the Las Vegas Raiders.
Huge win. Cousins was reunited with his head coach, Kevin O’Connell, and Cousins went straight into the starting lineup. I don’t know how that’s gonna work out. I’m filming this before, so I’m being optimistic. Nobody does. But look at what they did. In the middle of the season, they looked at the plan and they said, “This is not working.
We need to adjust, and we need to adjust now.” They did not wait for the off-season to feel uncomfortable. Why are you waiting? Almost every leader I work with can see the wrong seat, and almost every one of them waits too long. And here’s why. We don’t really talk about it. Many of us went through a school system that did not actually know how to educate us, and it gave up on us just because it ran out of ideas.
And unfortunately, we could not give up on it back. That’s illegal. We had to keep showing up because we had to apply ourselves somehow and get to graduation. There was no plan to help us, though. They’ve improved parts of that, but not a ton. Some of us turned out brilliant in ways nobody was guessing or measuring.
We were waiting for someone to give us a chance. So now, we believe everybody can do something with the right amount of support, and you know exactly what rejection and abandonment feel like, so you refuse to be the one who makes someone else feel that. I get it. I get it. That belief, it can be so strong, and it is a big reason people want to work for you.
It is also a massive blind spot. You get the benefit of the– You give the benefit of the doubt far too long and often. Resilience works the same way. You learn to give 150% when the odds were against you. Used on the wrong problem, it keeps you fighting for someone that will not change. I’ll give you a quick story.
One of my clients had a middle manager on a manufacturing plant floor, right? The manufacturer communicated… The manager communicated poorly, created drama, and struggled to delegate. Those are– That’s like lose, lose, lose. The goals and expectations for the team were immensely unclear. Most of the energy went into making sure nobody disliked him.
That was his goal. Turnover in that department ran three times higher than anywhere else in the entire plant, and production was down. So, the people who stayed were frustrated and angry, and they were staying because they couldn’t go anywhere else. My client could not make the call. This manager had been good and productive and loyal for years.
I get it. My client saw leadership potential worth growing, so my client sent the manager to training twice. After each round, things actually got worse, which the first time blew my mind. The second time, I wasn’t surprised. It went on for two years. Not one, two. Then my client moved the manager out of the role It was challenging, but he did.
The people who remained were so relieved. The culture improdu- improved and production went up. People stopped quitting and transferring to other departments. My client did a lot right First, he gave it full effort, clear expectations, and two rounds of training. What was missing was a line that said, “This is where we stop.
This is where I stop.” Now, look at what waiting can cost you. First and foremost that I see with most leaders, it’s your confidence. You start to second-guess yourself in other areas. I actually saw this leader’s sales going down. “If I can’t figure it out, maybe I do not know what I’m doing.” That’s another internal dialogue.
Here’s another one, “Maybe I should, maybe I shouldn’t be running the company.” Doubt, anxiety, old stories start to drain you. I watch it over and over again. And second, money. And it hi- you lose money, but it hides well. Replacing employees is expensive. More accidents happen when leadership is poor, and it hits the bottom line slowly, so no single decision gets blamed.
You can’t quite spot it on a profit and loss sheet, but it’s there. And waiting costs more than it used to. AI is changing roles and duties faster than job descriptions can keep up with. The person who fit a seat two years ago may not fit today. Nobody did anything wrong. The seat changed, and the seats are changing fast.
It is definitely a game of musical chairs. You and your leadership team have to pivot mid-season or sooner. Football coaches live with this every week. Any player can be out in minutes the second the ball gets kicked, even in practice. They keep a backup ready, and they train for the swap. So, who is your backup?
Who’s are other backups? Have you cross-trained everybody so you are not scrambling? Here is how I help clients decide when to cut their losses, ’cause this, like I said, this went on for two years. I wasn’t involved in all of it. Anyways, two checks come first. First, listen to the… I listen to the complaining and excuses.
A lot of either or a lot of both tells me how attached they are to the situation. That attachment will blur how you see things. Second, ask yourself if you can say exactly what this person needs to do. If you can, have you invested in helping them grow there? I had one client going on and on, “Oh, they just need to…”
And I’m like, “Have you helped them in any way?” “No, not yet.” There we go. There are six steps to this. Step one, name the seat. Write down what the role needs in plain words, and you’re gonna have to get good at this. Step two, check yourself. How much complaining, how many excuses are you hearing, uh, in your own head and from other people?
Step three, check the investment. Have you trained them on that exact skill? Or were they supposed to come in with that exact skill and it’s missing? What happened? Step four, look at the team under them. Turnover, output, mood, PTO days, injuries, pushback to change. Those are all hints. Step five, find the final piece.
What is the one thing you still need to know to confirm what others see? ‘Cause more than likely, other people are telling you, “It’s time for them to go.” Step six, set a date and write it down. Put it on your calendar with a code name, but set a date. People in roles sometimes expire, and we need to do that.
So think of that one seat that you are allowing to be just okay, whose name came up first. Write it down. One quick sentence of what is the next step that needs to happen, and then put a date on your calendar and a couple weeks for step five. If this landed for you, I’d love it. Please subscribe, so you do not miss out on any of the upcoming things.
If you’re ready to stop trying to figure all this out alone, that’d be my suggestion by the way, I have a free coaching session waiting for you at JoyGenea.com. The link is in the description, and drop a comment below and tell me what part of this hit close to home. And I’ll let you know, I love to read them.
So again, I’m JoyGenea Schumer, unconventional leadership coach and international neurodiversity coach. I am championing for you and the Minnesota Vikings now. Yay!
